Your browser is not supported or outdated so some features of the site might not be available.
- Table of Contents
- Top
- Main Differences
- Design
- Sound
- Isolation
- Microphone
- Active Features
- Connectivity
- Comments
Astro A40 TR Headset + MixAmp Pro 2017 vs Motorola Squads 200
Side-by-Side Comparison
Products
Astro A40 TR Headset + MixAmp Pro 2017
Motorola Squads 200
Tested using Methodology v1.5
Updated Feb 13, 2024 06:35 PM
SEE PRICE
Amazon.comTested using Methodology v1.4
Updated May 29, 2023 03:09 PM
SEE PRICE
Amazon.com
TypeOver-ear
EnclosureOpen-Back
WirelessNo
TransducerDynamic
Noise CancellingNo
MicYes
TypeOn-ear
EnclosureClosed-Back
WirelessNo
TransducerDynamic
Noise CancellingNo
MicYes
Variants
- A40 TR + MixAmp (PS4, MixAmp)
- A40 TR + MixAmp (Xbox One, MixAmp)
- Squads 200 (Blue)
- Squads 200 (Pink)
Our Verdict
Astro A40 TR Headset + MixAmp Pro 2017
Motorola Squads 200
The Astro A40 TR Headset + MixAmp Pro 2017 and the Motorola Squads 200 are two headphones designed for different purposes. The Motorola are kids headphones with an on-ear, closed-back fit. They offer a simple listening experience and even have an in-line mic for recording speech. However, the Astro are specifically designed for gaming and aren't kids' headphones. The Astro has an open-back, over-ear fit. They're more comfortable and have a MixAmp for channel mixing on-the-fly as well as companion software to customize their sound. However, some users have reported issues when using the software.
Notice: Two or more of the products selected have been tested with different test methodologies, so some of the results below aren't directly comparable. Learn how our test benches and scoring system work, and read more about the latest changes to our headphones test methodology.
Main Differences for
Threshold
Mixed Usage
4.7
Full Comparison
Design
Style
Design Picture 2
Type
Over-ear
On-ear
Enclosure
Open-Back
Closed-Back
Wireless
No
No
Transducer
Dynamic
Dynamic
Comfort
8.0
5.5
Comfort Picture
Weight
0.83 lbs
0.22 lbs
Clamping Force
0.9 lbs
0.4 lbs
Controls
6.2
6.3
Controls Picture
OS Compatibility
Not OS specific
Not OS specific
Ease Of Use
Good
Decent
Feedback
Good
Mediocre
Call/Music Control
No
Yes
Volume Control
Yes
Yes
Microphone Control
Mute/Unmute
No
Channel Mixing
Yes
No
Noise Cancelling Control
No
No
Talk-Through
No
No
Additional Controls
Presets + Surround Sound
No
Breathability
6.7
Breathability After Picture
Avg.Temp.Difference
5.1 °C
Portability
5.3
6.1
Portability Picture
L
7.2" (18.3 cm)
6"
W
7.5" (19.1 cm)
6.7"
H
4.0" (10.2 cm)
2.3"
Volume
216.00 in³ (3,539.59 cm³)
92.5 in³
Transmitter Required
No
No
Case
0.0
0.0
Case Picture
Type
No case
No case
L
N/A
N/A
W
N/A
N/A
H
N/A
N/A
Volume
N/A
N/A
Build Quality
8.0
6.0
Build Quality Picture
Stability
6.0
5.0
Stability Picture
Headshots 1
Angled Picture
Side Picture
Headshots 2
Front Picture
Rear Picture
Top
Top Picture
In The Box
In The Box Picture
Sound
Sound Profile
Frequency Response
Bass Amount
2 dB
-10.54 dB
Treble Amount
-4.29 dB
-3.55 dB
Frequency Response Consistency
5.8
6.4
Consistency L
Consistency R
Avg. Std. Deviation
1.03 dB
0.8 dB
Raw Frequency Response
Bass Accuracy
7.2
3.8
Std. Err.
4.43 dB
8.03 dB
Low-Frequency Extension
10 Hz
174.48 Hz
Low-Bass
1.7 dB
-14.7 dB
Mid-Bass
5.01 dB
-6.65 dB
High-Bass
5.99 dB
-0.79 dB
Mid Accuracy
8.7
7.1
Std. Err.
1.74 dB
3.92 dB
Low-Mid
2.05 dB
1.37 dB
Mid-Mid
0.13 dB
1.17 dB
High-Mid
0.58 dB
5.71 dB
Treble Accuracy
6.9
7.5
Std. Err.
4.63 dB
3.39 dB
Low-Treble
-4.52 dB
1.99 dB
Mid-Treble
-0.17 dB
-1.44 dB
High-Treble
-11.58 dB
-18.99 dB
Peaks/Dips
6.9
7.2
Peaks/Dips Graph
Peaks
2.12 dB
2.12 dB
Dips
1.35 dB
0.82 dB
Imaging
8.7
8.1
Phase Response
Phase Response Mismatch
Weighted Group Delay
0.17
0.11
Weighted Phase Mismatch
5.69
10.87
Weighted Amplitude Mismatch
0.16
0.8
Weighted Frequency Mismatch
2.25
2.55
Passive Soundstage
7.6
5.1
PRTF Accuracy (Std. Dev.)
1.39 dB
3.33 dB
PRTF Size (Avg.)
3.76 dB
4 dB
PRTF Distance
9.37 dB
1.4 dB
Openness
9.2
9.1
Acoustic Space Excitation
7.4
2.9
Virtual Soundstage
0.0
0.0
Virtual Soundstage
Head Modeling
No
No
Speaker Modeling
No
No
Room Ambience
No
No
Head Tracking
No
No
Virtual Surround
No
No App
Weighted Harmonic Distortion
7.1
7.3
Weighted Harmonic Distortion
WHD @ 90
0.388
0.321
WHD @ 100
0.296
0.252
Test Settings
Firmware
Unknown
No Firmware
Power
On
Passive
Connection
Wired
Wired
Codec
PCM, 24-bit, 48kHz
PCM, 24-bit, 48kHz
EQ
Default
No EQ
ANC
No ANC
No ANC
Tip/Pad
Default
Default
Microphone
Boom
In-line
Isolation
Noise Isolation
1.8
2.5
Noise Isolation
Isolation Audio
Overall Attenuation
-5.36 dB
-6.83 dB
Noise Cancelling
No
No
Bass
-0.2 dB
0.53 dB
Mid
-0.61 dB
0.12 dB
Treble
-15.08 dB
-20.83 dB
Leakage
3.6
7.5
Leakage Audio
Overall Leakage @ 1ft
55.68 dB
36.8 dB
Microphone
Microphone Style
Integrated
No
No
In-Line
No
Yes
Boom
Yes
No
Detachable Boom
Yes
No
Mic
Yes
Yes
Recording Quality
8.1
7.1
Microphone Frequency Response
Recorded Speech
LFE
20 Hz
276.97 Hz
FR Std. Dev.
2.46 dB
1.92 dB
HFE
4,627.75 Hz
2,832.31 Hz
Weighted THD
0.29
0.151
Gain
21.13 dB
10.53 dB
Noise Handling
8.3
6.1
SpNR
58.27 dB
13.33 dB
Noise Gate
Always On
Speech + Pink Noise Handling
8.5
Speech + Pink Noise Audio Sample
Speech + Subway Noise Handling
8.0
Speech + Subway Noise Audio Sample
Active Features
Battery
0.0
0.0
Battery Type
No Battery
No Battery
Continuous Battery Life
N/A
N/A
Additional Charges
N/A
N/A
Total Battery Life
N/A
N/A
Charge Time
N/A
N/A
Power-Saving Feature
No
No
Audio While Charging
No
No
Passive Playback
Passive Headphone
Passive Headphone
Charging Port
None
None
App Support
6.0
0.0
App Picture
App Name
Astro Command Center
No App
iOS
No
No
Android
No
No
macOS
Yes
No
Windows
Yes
No
Equalizer
Graphic + Presets
No
ANC Control
No
No
Mic Control
Adjustable Level
No
Room Effects
No
No
Playback Control
No
No
Button Mapping
No
No
Surround Support
No
No
Connectivity
Bluetooth
0.0
0.0
Bluetooth Version
No Bluetooth
No Bluetooth
Multi-Device Pairing
No
No
NFC Pairing
No
No
Line Of Sight Range
N/A
N/A
PC Latency (SBC)
N/A
N/A
PC Latency (aptX)
N/A
N/A
PC Latency (aptX HD)
N/A
N/A
PC Latency (aptX-LL)
N/A
N/A
iOS Latency
N/A
N/A
Android Latency
N/A
N/A
Non-Bluetooth Wireless
0.0
0.0
Non-BT Line Of Sight Range
N/A
N/A
Non-BT Latency
N/A
N/A
Wired
9.5
9.0
Cable Picture
Analog Audio
Yes
Yes
USB Audio
USB Type A
No
Detachable
Yes
No
Length
6.80 ft (2.07 m)
2.8 ft
Connection
1/8" TRRS
1/8" TRRS
Analog/USB Audio Latency
20 ms
0 ms
PC Compatibility
Analog
Audio + Microphone
Wired USB
Audio + Microphone
Non-BT Wireless
No
PC / PS4 Compatibility
PC/PS4 Analog
Audio + Microphone
Audio + Microphone
PC/PS4 Wired USB
Audio Only
No
PC/PS4 Non-BT Wireless
No
No
PlayStation Compatibility
PS4 Analog
Audio + Microphone
Audio + Microphone
PS4 Wired USB
Audio Only
No
PS4 Non-BT Wireless
No
No
PS5 Analog
Audio + Microphone
PS5 Wired USB
No
PS5 Non-BT Wireless
No
Xbox Compatibility
Xbox One Analog
Audio + Microphone
Audio + Microphone
Xbox One Wired USB
Audio + Microphone
No
Xbox One Non-BT Wireless
No
No
Xbox Series X|S Analog
Audio + Microphone
Xbox Series X|S Wired USB
No
Xbox Series X|S Non-BT Wireless
No
Base/Dock
7.8
0.0
Type
Wired USB dock
No Base/Dock
USB Input
Yes
No
Line In
Yes
No
Line Out
Yes
No
Optical Input
Yes
No
RCA Input
No
No
Dock Charging
No
No
Power Supply
USB
No Base/Dock
Astro A40 TR Headset + MixAmp Pro 2017
Motorola Squads 200
Comments
Astro A40 TR Headset + MixAmp Pro 2017 vs Motorola Squads 200: Main Discussion
What do you think of these products? Let us know below.
Looking for a personalized buying advice from the RTINGS.com experts? Insiders have direct access to buying advice on our insider forum.