Your browser is not supported or outdated so some features of the site might not be available.
- Table of Contents
- Top
- Main Differences
- Design
- Display
- Interface
- Connectivity
- Configuration
- Performance
- Additional Features And Software
- Comments
ASUS TUF Gaming A16 Advantage Edition (2023) vs MSI Katana A15 AI (2024)
Side-by-Side Comparison
Products
ASUS TUF Gaming A16 Advantage Edition (2023)
MSI Katana A15 AI (2024)
Tested using Methodology v0.8.2
Updated Nov 19, 2024 04:18 PM
SEE PRICE
Amazon.comTested using Methodology v0.8.2
Updated Nov 20, 2024 03:19 PM
SEE PRICE
Amazon.com
Size16"
Operating SystemWindows 11
Size15.6"
Operating SystemWindows 11
Variants
- TUF Gaming A16 Advantage Edition (FA617NS-DS71-CA) (Black - 165Hz/Ryzen 7 7735HS/Radeon RX 7600S/16GB/1TB)
- TUF Gaming A16 Advantage Edition (FA617NS-A16.R77600) (Black - 165Hz/Ryzen 7 7735HS/Radeon RX7600S/16GB/512GB)
- TUF Gaming A16 Advantage Edition (FA617NT-A16.R77700) (Black - 165Hz/Ryzen 7 7735HS/Radeon RX7700S/16GB/512GB)
- Katana A15 AI (B8VF-448US) (Black - FHD/144Hz/Ryzen 7 8845HS/RTX 4060/32GB/1TB)
- Katana A15 AI (B8VF-406CA) (Black - FHD/144Hz/Ryzen 9 8945HS/RTX 4060/32GB/1TB)
- Katana A15 AI (B8VG-423US) (Black - FHD/144Hz/Ryzen 9 8945HS/RTX 4070/16GB/1TB)
- Katana A15 AI (B8VG-430US) (Black - QHD/165Hz/Ryzen 7 8845HS/RTX 4070/16GB/1TB)
- Katana A15 AI (B8VG-450US) (Black - QHD/165Hz/Ryzen 9 8945HS/RTX 4070/32GB/1TB)
Our Verdict
ASUS TUF Gaming A16 Advantage Edition (2023)
MSI Katana A15 AI (2024)
The MSI Katana A15 AI (2024) and the ASUS TUF Gaming A16 Advantage Edition (2023) are both excellent budget gaming laptops. The MSI is a better option if you're only looking for the best performance, as its Zen 4 AMD CPUs and NVIDIA 40-series GPUs are faster; however, the ASUS has a faster 240Hz display option, which will give you better responsiveness and smoother motion than the displays available on the MSI. In terms of the overall user experience, the ASUS is much better; it has a sturdier build, a larger touchpad, a wider port selection, and significantly longer battery life in light uses.
Main Differences for
Threshold
School
7.6
6.2
Battery
9.1
3.7
Build Quality
8.5
7.0
Portability
6.1
5.5
Full Comparison
Design
Style
Style Photo
Form Factor
Traditional (Clamshell)
Traditional (Clamshell)
Build Quality
8.5
7.0
Build Quality Photo
Hinge
9.1
5.8
Hinge Photo
Range
135°
180°
Stability
Good
Decent
One Finger Lift
Yes
No
Portability
6.1
5.5
Dimensions Photo
Size
16"
15.6"
Thickness
1.1" (2.9 cm)
1.4" (3.5 cm)
Width
14.0" (35.6 cm)
14.1" (35.9 cm)
Depth
10.1" (25.6 cm)
10.4" (26.4 cm)
Volume
161.3 in³ (2,642.9 cm³)
202.4 in³ (3,317.2 cm³)
Weight
4.8 lbs (2.2 kg)
5.1 lbs (2.3 kg)
Charger Size
19.3 in³ (316.1 cm³)
17.8 in³ (292.2 cm³)
Charger Weight
1.5 lbs (0.7 kg)
1.7 lbs (0.8 kg)
Serviceability
8.4
8.1
Internals Photo
Ease Of Access
7.5
7.0
RAM Slots
2
2
Storage Slots
2
2
Replaceable Battery
Yes
Yes
Replaceable Wireless Adapter
Yes
Yes
In The Box
In The Box Photo
Display
Screen Specs
Display Photo
Resolution
1920 x 1200
1920 x 1080
Aspect Ratio
16:10
16:9
Pixel Density
142 PPI
141 PPI
Panel Type
IPS
IPS
Touch Screen
No
No
Screen-To-Body Ratio
88%
73%
Refresh Rate
9.1
8.9
Motion Blur
Refresh Rate
165 Hz
144 Hz
Variable Refresh Rate
FreeSync
FreeSync
Contrast
7.5
7.8
Contrast Photo
Native Contrast
1,430 : 1
1,599 : 1
Brightness
6.4
6.4
Maximum Brightness
258 cd/m²
250 cd/m²
Minimum Brightness
23 cd/m²
12 cd/m²
Reflections
7.7
8.2
Reflections Photo Off
Reflections Photo Max
Screen Finish
Matte
Matte
Total Reflections
4.49%
3.71%
Indirect Reflections
3.1%
3.2%
Calculated Direct Reflections
1.39%
0.51%
Black Uniformity
5.3
6.4
Black Uniformity Photo
Uniformity (Std. Dev.)
2.426%
1.724%
Horizontal Viewing Angle
6.4
6.5
Horizontal Viewing Angle Video
Horizontal Chroma Picture
Color Washout From Left
25°
23°
Color Washout From Right
23°
22°
Horizontal Hue Picture
Color Shift From Left
38°
48°
Color Shift From Right
32°
52°
Horizontal Lightness Picture
Brightness Loss From Left
28°
25°
Brightness Loss From Right
26°
25°
Black Level Raise From Left
60°
60°
Black Level Raise From Right
60°
60°
Gamma Shift From Left
26°
21°
Gamma Shift From Right
23°
22°
Vertical Viewing Angle
6.4
6.4
Vertical Viewing Angle Video
Vertical Chroma Picture
Color Washout From Below
25°
24°
Color Washout From Above
24°
24°
Vertical Hue Picture
Color Shift From Below
37°
38°
Color Shift From Above
29°
41°
Vertical Lightness Picture
Brightness Loss From Below
27°
25°
Brightness Loss From Above
25°
24°
Black Level Raise From Below
45°
45°
Black Level Raise From Above
45°
45°
Gamma Shift From Below
28°
23°
Gamma Shift From Above
25°
24°
Out-Of-The-Box Color Accuracy
9.7
6.2
White Balance Screencap
Gamma Curve Screencap
Color Screencap
Avg. White Balance dE
1.68
3.14
Avg. Gamma
2.18
2.32
Avg. Color dE
1.41
4.81
Avg. Color Temperature
6,422 K
7,212 K
Color Gamut
8.6
4.5
Gamut SDR
sRGB xy
99.73%
69.37%
sRGB uv
99.4%
57.46%
Adobe RGB xy
77.13%
51.18%
Adobe RGB uv
86.5%
50.47%
Gamut HDR
DCI P3 xy
78.9%
50.8%
DCI P3 uv
84.31%
46.64%
Rec. 2020 xy
56.6%
36.53%
Rec. 2020 uv
61.45%
34.22%
Flicker
10
10
Flicker Graph
Flicker-Free
Yes
Yes
Flicker Frequency
No Flicker
No Flicker
Flicker Active Below
0%
0%
Interface
Keyboard
8.1
8.6
Keyboard Photo
Typing Quality
8.0
8.5
Numpad
Yes
Yes
Backlighting
Adjustable
RGB Zones
Key Switch Actuation Graph
Operating Force
62 gf
68 gf
Actuation Force
35 gf
32 gf
Pre-Travel
1.01 mm
1.03 mm
Total Travel
1.34 mm
1.53 mm
Touchpad
8.0
7.1
Touchpad Photo
Tracking Quality
8.0
7.5
Size
15.3 in² (98.9 cm²)
10.5 in² (68.1 cm²)
Material
Plastic
Plastic
Dedicated Buttons
No
No
Speakers
7.6
4.8
Frequency Response Plot
Max Volume
73 dB SPL
72 dB SPL
Standard Error @ Normal Vol. (65 dB)
3.9 dB
10.7 dB
Slope @ Normal Vol. (65 dB)
-0.3
3.7
Bass Extension (Low-Frequency Ext.)
293 Hz
230 Hz
Treble Extension (High-Frequency Ext.)
20 kHz
18 kHz
Dynamic Range Compression @ Max Vol.
2.1 dB
1.9 dB
Webcam & Microphone
5.3
4.8
Webcam Video Sample
Video Quality
5.0
4.5
Resolution
720p
720p
Position
Top Center
Top Center
Privacy Cover
No
No
Face Unlock
No
No
Connectivity
Ports
8.0
7.5
Ports Photo
USB-A Ports
2
3
USB-C Ports
2
1
Thunderbolt
No
No
USB-C Charging
Yes
No
USB-C Display Out
Yes
Yes
HDMI
2.1
2.1
DisplayPort
No
No
3.5mm Jack
Combo mic/headphone
Combo mic/headphone
Card Reader
No
No
Ethernet
Yes
Yes
Proprietary Port
No
No
Security Lock
Yes
No
Wireless Communication
Wi-Fi
Wi-Fi 6 (802.11ax)
Wi-Fi 6E (802.11ax)
Bluetooth
5.3
5.3
Configuration
CPU
Brand
AMD
AMD
Model
Ryzen 7 7735HS
Ryzen 9 8945HS
Core Count
8
8
Thread Count
16
16
GPU
Brand
AMD
NVIDIA
Model
Radeon RX 7600S
GeForce RTX 4060 Laptop GPU
Dedicated/Integrated
Dedicated
Dedicated
VRAM Size
8 GB
8 GB
RAM
Capacity
16 GB
32 GB
Modules
2
2
Type
DDR5
DDR5
Speed
4,800 MHz
5,600 MHz
Storage
Advertised Capacity
1,000 GB
1,000 GB
Usable Capacity
928 GB
926 GB
Drive 1
Western Digital PC SN560 SDDPNQE-1T00-1002
WD PC SN560 SDDPNQR-1T00-1032
Drive 1 Type
SSD
SSD
Drive 2
No 2nd Drive
No 2nd Drive
Drive 2 Type
No 2nd Drive
No 2nd Drive
Performance
Geekbench 5 (Synthetics)
9.5
9.9
Geekbench Image
CPU Single-Thread
1,553 points
1,933 points
CPU Multi-Thread
9,503 points
11,823 points
GPU Compute
71,011 points
104,655 points
Cinebench R23 (CPU Rendering)
9.7
9.9
Cinebench R23 Photo
Single-Thread
1,525 points
1,747 points
Multi-Thread
13,314 points
16,162 points
Blender (3D Rendering)
8.5
9.3
Blender Image
CPU Render Time
3.1 min
2.6 min
GPU Render Time
N/A
0.4 min
GPU Render Time (Optix)
N/A
10 s
Basemark GPU (Game Scene)
9.5
9.6
Basemark Image
Overall Score
99,513
109,009
Storage Drive Performance
9.2
9.4
Storage Performance Image
Sequential Write Speed
1,564.1 MB/s
1,138.2 MB/s
Sequential Read Speed
3,550.5 MB/s
3,976.4 MB/s
Random Write Speed
73.2 MB/s
101.5 MB/s
Random Read Speed
45.4 MB/s
62.3 MB/s
Battery
9.1
3.7
Capacity
90 Wh
54 Wh
Battery Life (Web Browsing)
12.9 hrs
4.0 hrs
Battery Life (Video Playback)
9.2 hrs
3.8 hrs
Battery Life (Gaming)
1.3 hrs
1.1 hrs
Charge Time
1.8 hrs
3.3 hrs
Borderlands 3
8.4
7.7
Borderlands 3 Graph
Avg. FPS
113 fps
96 fps
1% Low
72 fps
60 fps
0.1% Low
49 fps
31 fps
1% Low Delta
5 ms
6 ms
0.1% Low Delta
12 ms
21 ms
Avg. FPS On Very Low
174 fps
204 fps
Civilization VI
8.9
8.4
Civilization VI Graph
Avg. FPS
156 fps
168 fps
1% Low
111 fps
94 fps
0.1% Low
106 fps
48 fps
1% Low Delta
3 ms
5 ms
0.1% Low Delta
3 ms
15 ms
Avg. FPS On Minimum
276 fps
258 fps
Avg. Turn Time
6.65 s
6.63 s
Counter-Strike: Global Offensive
CS:GO graph
Avg. FPS
1% Low
0.1% Low
1% Low Delta
0.1% Low Delta
Avg. FPS On Low
Counter-Strike 2
9.2
8.5
Avg. FPS
187fps
230fps
1% Low
102fps
69fps
0.1% Low
75fps
52fps
1% Low Delta
4 ms
10 ms
0.1% Low Delta
8 ms
15 ms
Avg. FPS On Low
225fps
349fps
Shadow Of The Tomb Raider
7.2
9.1
Avg. FPS
104 fps
135 fps
1% Low
49 fps
100 fps
0.1% Low
26 fps
78 fps
1% Low Delta
11 ms
3 ms
0.1% Low Delta
29 ms
5 ms
Avg. FPS On Lowest
193 fps
178 fps
Thermals And Noise
5.9
6.8
Keyboard Temps Picture
Keyboard Temp While Idle
39 °C (102 °F)
32 °C (90 °F)
Keyboard Temp Under Load
54 °C (128 °F)
49 °C (119 °F)
Fan Noise While Idle
25.0 dBA
25.0 dBA
Fan Noise Under Load
49.0 dBA
47.5 dBA
Power & Fan Control App
Yes
Yes
Performance Over Time
10
10
Performance Over Time Graph
CPU Temp (Cinebench)
84 °C
67 °C
CPU Perf. Loss (Cinebench)
0% loss
0% loss
GPU Temp (Heaven)
55 °C
67 °C
GPU Perf. Loss (Heaven)
0% loss
0% loss
Additional Features And Software
Software
Operating System
Windows 11
Windows 11
Additional Software
Yes
Yes
Extra Features
RGB Illumination
No
Yes
Touch Pen
No
No
Secondary Display
No
No
Biometrics
No
No
You have 10/10 free reviews left
To access
and
Become an Insider
unlimited full product reviews,
product prices
other exclusive site features
ASUS TUF Gaming A16 Advantage Edition (2023)
MSI Katana A15 AI (2024)
Comments
ASUS TUF Gaming A16 Advantage Edition (2023) vs MSI Katana A15 AI (2024): Main Discussion
What do you think of these products? Let us know below.
Looking for a personalized buying advice from the RTINGS.com experts? Insiders have direct access to buying advice on our insider forum.