Notice: Your browser is not supported or outdated so some features of the site might not be available.
Brother MFC-L8905CDW [MFC-L8895CDW, MFC-L8900CDW] vs HP Color LaserJet Pro MFP 4301fdw/4301fdn
Side-by-Side Comparison
Products
Brother MFC-L8905CDW [MFC-L8895CDW, MFC-L8900CDW]
HP Color LaserJet Pro MFP 4301fdw/4301fdn
Tested using Methodology v1.2
Updated Feb 11, 2025 02:47 PM
SEE PRICE
Amazon.comTested using Methodology v1.2
Updated Dec 17, 2024 02:10 PM
SEE PRICE
Amazon.com![Brother MFC-L8905CDW [MFC-L8895CDW, MFC-L8900CDW] Picture](https://i.rtings.com/assets/products/1rHShTlA/brother-mfc-l8905cdw-mfc-l8895cdw-mfc-l8900cdw/design-large.jpg?format=auto)
TypeAll-In-One
TechnologyLaser
SuperTankNo
WirelessYes
ColorYes
TypeAll in One
TechnologyLaser
SuperTankNo
WirelessYes
ColorYes
Variants
- MFC-L8905CDW (White)
- MFC-L8900CDW (White)
- MFC-L8610CDW (White)
- Color LaserJet Pro MFP 4301fdw (White/Blue)
- Color LaserJet Pro MFP 4301fdn (White/Blue)
- Color LaserJet Pro MFP 4301dw (White/Blue)
- Color LaserJet Pro MFP 4302fdw (White/Blue)
- Color LaserJet Pro MFP 4302dw (White/Blue)
- Color LaserJet Pro MFP 4302fdn (White/Blue)
- Color LaserJet Pro MFP 4303dw (White/Blue)
- Color LaserJet Pro MFP 4303fdn (White/Blue)
- Color LaserJet Pro MFP 4303fdw (White/Blue)
Our Verdict
Brother MFC-L8905CDW [MFC-L8895CDW, MFC-L8900CDW]
HP Color LaserJet Pro MFP 4301fdw/4301fdn
The Brother MFC-L8905CDW is better than the HP Color LaserJet Pro MFP 4301fdw/4301fdn for most uses. The Brother yields more prints, so you won't have to spend as much on toner. It has a scanner with adjustable lid hinges, and its optical character recognition is built-in, meaning you don't need a third-party app to use it. It also processes sheets faster through the ADF and produces higher-quality scans. On the other hand, the HP prints faster.
Check Price
White
MFC-L8905CDW
SEE PRICE
Amazon.comWhite/Blue
Color LaserJet Pro MFP 4301fdw
SEE PRICE
Amazon.comWhite
MFC-L8900CDW
SEE PRICE
Amazon.comWhite/Blue
Color LaserJet Pro MFP 4301fdn
SEE PRICE
Amazon.comWhite
MFC-L8610CDW
SEE PRICE
Amazon.comWhite/Blue
Color LaserJet Pro MFP 4301dw
SEARCH
Amazon.comWhite/Blue
Color LaserJet Pro MFP 4302fdw
SEARCH
Amazon.comWhite/Blue
Color LaserJet Pro MFP 4302dw
SEARCH
Amazon.comWhite/Blue
Color LaserJet Pro MFP 4302fdn
SEE PRICE
Amazon.comWhite/Blue
Color LaserJet Pro MFP 4303dw
SEE PRICE
Amazon.comWhite/Blue
Color LaserJet Pro MFP 4303fdn
SEARCH
Amazon.comWhite/Blue
Color LaserJet Pro MFP 4303fdw
SEARCH
Amazon.comMain Differences forFamily
Family
Threshold
Family
8.2
7.6
Cost-Per-Print
8.6
7.4
Expected Maintenance
8.5
7.0
Small Details
4.5
3.0
Full Comparison
Design
Build Quality
9.0
7.5
Build Quality Close Up
![Brother MFC-L8905CDW [MFC-L8895CDW, MFC-L8900CDW] Build Quality Close Up](https://i.rtings.com/assets/products/DfALVuGF/brother-mfc-l8905cdw-mfc-l8895cdw-mfc-l8900cdw/build-quality-large.jpg?format=auto)
Type
All-In-One
All in One
Dimensions
ISO View Picture
![Brother MFC-L8905CDW [MFC-L8895CDW, MFC-L8900CDW] ISO View Picture](https://i.rtings.com/assets/products/kdDBpPdu/brother-mfc-l8905cdw-mfc-l8895cdw-mfc-l8900cdw/size-large.jpg?format=auto)
Height
21.9" (55.5 cm)
15.0" (38.0 cm)
Width
19.5" (49.5 cm)
16.6" (42.1 cm)
Depth
20.1" (51.0 cm)
16.8" (42.7 cm)
In Use Picture
![Brother MFC-L8905CDW [MFC-L8895CDW, MFC-L8900CDW] In Use Picture](https://i.rtings.com/assets/products/jR6cosOf/brother-mfc-l8905cdw-mfc-l8895cdw-mfc-l8900cdw/in-use-large.jpg?format=auto)
Height When In Use
21.9" (55.5 cm)
15.0" (38.0 cm)
Width When In Use
21.3" (54.0 cm)
16.8" (42.7 cm)
Depth When In Use
20.1" (51.0 cm)
24.8" (63.1 cm)
Weight
50.0 lbs (22.7 kg)
45.0 lbs (20.4 kg)
Expected Maintenance
8.5
7.0
Ink Related Maintenance
Not Needed
Not Needed
Drum Unit
A Separate Unit
In The Cartridge
Display Screen
8.5
9.5
Display Screen Picture
![Brother MFC-L8905CDW [MFC-L8895CDW, MFC-L8900CDW] Display Screen Picture](https://i.rtings.com/assets/products/AjYczbua/brother-mfc-l8905cdw-mfc-l8895cdw-mfc-l8900cdw/controls-large.jpg?format=auto)
Display Screen
Yes
Yes
Display Screen Size
7.1" (18.0 cm)
4.3" (10.8 cm)
Touchscreen
Yes
Yes
Cartridge
9.3
9.1
Cartridge Picture In The Printer
![Brother MFC-L8905CDW [MFC-L8895CDW, MFC-L8900CDW] Cartridge Picture In The Printer](https://i.rtings.com/assets/products/TSEy9OJU/brother-mfc-l8905cdw-mfc-l8895cdw-mfc-l8900cdw/cartridge-large.jpg?format=auto)
Technology
Laser
Laser
SuperTank
No
No
Photo Cartridge
No
No
Color
Yes
Yes
Number Of Color Cartridges
3
3
Black Cartridge Model
TN431BK
HP 210A Black
Tested Black Page Yield
153 prints
120.89 prints
Estimated Black Page Yield
2,907 prints
2,297 prints
Color Cartridge Model
TN431 C/M/Y
HP 210A C/M/Y
Tested Color Page Yield
68 prints
66.01 prints
Estimated Color Page Yield
1,446 prints
1,404 prints
Third Party Cartridge
Not Found At Time Of The Review
Not Found At Time Of The Review
Ink Type
Toner
Toner
High Yield Cartridge
Yes
Yes
Scanner Features
9.7
9.4
Scanner Flatbed Picture
![Brother MFC-L8905CDW [MFC-L8895CDW, MFC-L8900CDW] Scanner Flatbed Picture](https://i.rtings.com/assets/products/xVeUIQHG/brother-mfc-l8905cdw-mfc-l8895cdw-mfc-l8900cdw/scanner-large.jpg?format=auto)
Scanner
ADF + Flatbed
ADF + Flatbed
ADF Capacity
70 pages
50 pages
Scan Speed
32 PPM
29 PPM
Duplex Scanning
Automatic (Single-Pass)
Automatic (Single-Pass)
Max Flatbed Scan Size
8.5" x 14"
8.5" x 11"
Max ADF Scan Size
8.5" x 14"
8.5" x 14"
Flatbed Hinge Adjustability
0.69" (18 mm)
0.00" (0 mm)
Fax
Yes
Yes
Copy
Yes
Yes
OCR Included
Built-in
Third Party Only
Scan Quality
9.5
8.0
Scan Quality Photo
![Brother MFC-L8905CDW [MFC-L8895CDW, MFC-L8900CDW] Scan Quality Photo](https://i.rtings.com/assets/products/RUBgymIi/brother-mfc-l8905cdw-mfc-l8895cdw-mfc-l8900cdw/scanner-sample-large.jpg?format=auto)
Max Scan Resolution
1,200 DPI
1,200 DPI
Max Scan Color Depth
24Bit
30Bit
In The Box
In the Box Picture
![Brother MFC-L8905CDW [MFC-L8895CDW, MFC-L8900CDW] In the Box Picture](https://i.rtings.com/assets/products/9HwTzkNH/brother-mfc-l8905cdw-mfc-l8895cdw-mfc-l8900cdw/in-the-box-large.jpg?format=auto)
Battery
Advertised Battery Life
N/A
N/A
Tested Charging Time
N/A
N/A
Document
Black & White Documents
9.5
9.5
B&W Document Picture
![Brother MFC-L8905CDW [MFC-L8895CDW, MFC-L8900CDW] B&W Document Picture](https://i.rtings.com/assets/products/SPxBQpoz/brother-mfc-l8905cdw-mfc-l8895cdw-mfc-l8900cdw/black-white-large.jpg?format=auto)
Color Ink Needed For Black & White
Yes
No
Color Documents
9.5
9.5
Color Document Picture
![Brother MFC-L8905CDW [MFC-L8895CDW, MFC-L8900CDW] Color Document Picture](https://i.rtings.com/assets/products/3oO9vZww/brother-mfc-l8905cdw-mfc-l8895cdw-mfc-l8900cdw/color-large.jpg?format=auto)
Cost-Per-Print
8.6
7.4
Printer Total Cost
Black Cartridge Price
80.99 US$
96.9 US$
Color Cartridge Price
218.49 US$
350.97 US$
Black-Only Printing Cost
0.028 US$/print
0.042 US$/print
Color Printing Cost
0.151 US$/print
0.250 US$/print
Photo Printing Cost
0.401 US$/print
0.663 US$/print
Ink Subscription
Optional
No
Printing Speed
8.9
9.1
Printing Speed Video
Black Only Text Document
32 PPM
35 PPM
Color Document
32 PPM
35 PPM
Photo Printing Time
28.0 s
19.0 s
Single Page Out Time (Black Only)
15.0 s
12.0 s
Duplex Printing
Automatic
Automatic
Input Tray Capacity
300 pages
300 pages
Document Printing Sizes
Letter (8.5" x 11")
Yes
Yes
Legal (8.5" x 14")
Yes
Yes
Tabloid (11" x 17")
No
No
A6 (105mm x 148mm)
Yes
Yes
A5 (148mm x 210mm)
Yes
Yes
A4 (210mm x 297mm)
Yes
Yes
Max Paper Weight
163 g/m²
200 g/m²
Photo
Color Gamut
5.0
5.0
Parrots Picture
![Brother MFC-L8905CDW [MFC-L8895CDW, MFC-L8900CDW] Parrots Picture](https://i.rtings.com/assets/products/NXkHz8Nv/brother-mfc-l8905cdw-mfc-l8895cdw-mfc-l8900cdw/parrots-large.jpg?format=auto)
Color Range Picture
![Brother MFC-L8905CDW [MFC-L8895CDW, MFC-L8900CDW] Color Range Picture](https://i.rtings.com/assets/products/iCccTKdu/brother-mfc-l8905cdw-mfc-l8895cdw-mfc-l8900cdw/color-gamut-large.jpg?format=auto)
Color Accuracy
5.6
6.7
Friends Picture
![Brother MFC-L8905CDW [MFC-L8895CDW, MFC-L8900CDW] Friends Picture](https://i.rtings.com/assets/products/lxURiXrG/brother-mfc-l8905cdw-mfc-l8895cdw-mfc-l8900cdw/friends-large.jpg?format=auto)
Color dE Picture
![Brother MFC-L8905CDW [MFC-L8895CDW, MFC-L8900CDW] Color dE Picture](https://i.rtings.com/assets/products/6amxzP0n/brother-mfc-l8905cdw-mfc-l8895cdw-mfc-l8900cdw/color-de-large.jpg?format=auto)
Color dE Graph
![Brother MFC-L8905CDW [MFC-L8895CDW, MFC-L8900CDW] Color dE Graph](https://i.rtings.com/assets/products/sIOV4kiu/brother-mfc-l8905cdw-mfc-l8895cdw-mfc-l8900cdw/de-bargraph-large.jpg?format=auto)
Average Color dE
9.02
6.80
Small Details
4.5
3.0
Small Details Photo
![Brother MFC-L8905CDW [MFC-L8895CDW, MFC-L8900CDW] Small Details Photo](https://i.rtings.com/assets/products/M0wJApsl/brother-mfc-l8905cdw-mfc-l8895cdw-mfc-l8900cdw/tokyo-large.jpg?format=auto)
Max Print Resolution (DPI)
2400 x 600
600 x 600
Photo Printing Sizes
0.0
0.0
Glossy Paper (4" x 6")
No
No
Glossy Paper (5" x 7")
No
No
Glossy Paper (8" x 10")
No
No
Glossy Paper (8.5" x 11")
No
No
Glossy Paper (13" x 19")
No
No
Borderless Printing
No
No
Mobile App And Connectivity
Connectivity
9.0
9.0
Inputs Picture
![Brother MFC-L8905CDW [MFC-L8895CDW, MFC-L8900CDW] Inputs Picture](https://i.rtings.com/assets/products/x2YUKSzR/brother-mfc-l8905cdw-mfc-l8895cdw-mfc-l8900cdw/inputs-large.jpg?format=auto)
Ethernet
Yes
Yes
USB Input To Computer
Yes
Yes
Bluetooth
No
No
Wireless
Yes
Yes
Wi-Fi via Router
Yes
Yes
Wi-Fi Direct
Yes
Yes
External Storage Support
Yes
Yes
Apple AirPrint
Yes
Yes
Mopria Print Service
Yes
Yes
Mobile App
10
10
App Printscreen
![Brother MFC-L8905CDW [MFC-L8895CDW, MFC-L8900CDW] App Printscreen](https://i.rtings.com/assets/products/vOSgrxGC/brother-mfc-l8905cdw-mfc-l8895cdw-mfc-l8900cdw/app-printscreen-large.jpg?format=auto)
Mobile App
Yes
Yes
App Name
Brother iPrint&Scan
HP Smart
iOS
Yes
Yes
Android
Yes
Yes
Photo (JPEG, PNG)
Android and iOS
Android and iOS
PDF
Android and iOS
Android and iOS
Microsoft Office Files
Android and iOS
iOS Only
Text Files (TXT)
Android and iOS
iOS Only
Webpages (HTML)
Android and iOS
iOS Only
OS Compatibility
Windows
Fully
Fully
macOS
Fully
Fully
Chrome OS
Fully
Fully
Check Price
White
MFC-L8905CDW
SEE PRICE
Amazon.comWhite/Blue
Color LaserJet Pro MFP 4301fdw
SEE PRICE
Amazon.comWhite
MFC-L8900CDW
SEE PRICE
Amazon.comWhite/Blue
Color LaserJet Pro MFP 4301fdn
SEE PRICE
Amazon.comWhite
MFC-L8610CDW
SEE PRICE
Amazon.comWhite/Blue
Color LaserJet Pro MFP 4301dw
SEARCH
Amazon.comWhite/Blue
Color LaserJet Pro MFP 4302fdw
SEARCH
Amazon.comWhite/Blue
Color LaserJet Pro MFP 4302dw
SEARCH
Amazon.comWhite/Blue
Color LaserJet Pro MFP 4302fdn
SEE PRICE
Amazon.comWhite/Blue
Color LaserJet Pro MFP 4303dw
SEE PRICE
Amazon.comWhite/Blue
Color LaserJet Pro MFP 4303fdn
SEARCH
Amazon.comWhite/Blue
Color LaserJet Pro MFP 4303fdw
SEARCH
Amazon.com
You have 10/10 free reviews left
To access
and
Become an Insider
unlimited full product reviews,
product prices
other exclusive site features
Brother MFC-L8905CDW [MFC-L8895CDW, MFC-L8900CDW]
HP Color LaserJet Pro MFP 4301fdw/4301fdn
Comments
Brother MFC-L8905CDW [MFC-L8895CDW, MFC-L8900CDW] vs HP Color LaserJet Pro MFP 4301fdw/4301fdn: Main Discussion
What do you think of these products? Let us know below.
Looking for a personalized buying advice from the RTINGS.com experts? Insiders have direct access to buying advice on our insider forum.